Imperfect 'Body'
Despite memorable set pieces, dialogue, Ridley Scott thriller trips over ridiculous plot
Last Modified: Friday, October 10, 2008 at 6:46 a.m.
“Rendition.” “Redacted.” “The Kingdom.” “In the Valley of Elah.” “Lions for Lambs.”
Stars: Leonardo DiCaprio, Russell Crowe, Mark Strong, Golshifteh Farahani, Oscar Isaac, Alon Aboutboul, Simon McBurney
Director: Ridley Scott
Rating: R for strong violence including some torture, and for language throughout
Running time: 129 minutes
Playing: Airport, Petaluma, Raven, Reading, Roxy, Sebastopol, Sonoma
Bottom line: Some elements you can believe, but too much is sensationally implausible.
They’re all movies about the war on terror that nobody has wanted to see, either because the topic is too daunting or too much of a downer, or it’s simply too soon after 9/11.
Soon, you’ll be able to add “Body of Lies” to that list, even though it’s probably the most worthwhile and least preachy of the bunch.
The pieces would all seem to be in place for a compelling take on this complex topic: strong work from acting heavyweights Russell Crowe and Leonardo DiCaprio; an intricate script from William Monahan, an Academy Award winner for “The Departed”; and the virtuoso visual styling of director Ridley Scott.
Of course, it looks great as it bounces breathlessly between Iraq and Jordan, Qatar and the Netherlands, Dubai and the Virginia suburbs; Scott seamlessly blends footage shot by overhead drones with intense, paranoid sequences from the cramped streets below.
And yet the result, with its many explosions and shootouts, too often feels like a generic action picture, albeit one with weightier stuff on its mind. It’s as if Scott & Co. felt they needed to make the material palatable to the widest possible audience by turning it into a familiar genre picture, rather than sticking to their guns and making, well, “Syriana.”
Based on the novel of the same name by Washington Post columnist David Ignatius, whose knowledge of the subject matter would seem to be unimpeachable, “Body of Lies” follows undercover CIA operative Roger Ferris (DiCaprio), who’s trying to ferret out the mastermind behind a series of anonymous bombings around the world. At the same time, Ferris’ boss, Ed Hoffman (Crowe), is running surveillance and plotting strategy from home back in the United States with the help of his ever-present cell-phone headset and laptop.
But despite their shared goals and mutual dependence, Ferris and Hoffman often end up miscommunicating and undermining each other.
This becomes especially true when Ferris tries to chat up the smooth Jordanian intelligence chief (Mark Strong, who nearly steals the whole movie), a man who holds Hoffman in disdain and has been reluctant to aid in the CIA’s efforts. Strong’s character, Hani, is impeccably dressed and respectful — he repeatedly refers to Ferris as “My dear,” which seems to be more of a threat than a term of endearment — but that classy demeanor only makes his dark side more frightening.
Somehow, with all his copious free time, Ferris manages to romance Aisha (Golshifteh Farahani), a pretty, soft-spoken nurse who treats his wounds when he gets particularly banged up during a chase in Amman. It’s obvious what the purpose of the relationship is — it’s a device meant to flesh out Ferris and reveal whatever glimmers of humanity he may have left in this deadly world — but it feels distractingly wedged-in. It’s also a way to inject a rare female figure, but her presence seems like something out of an old-fashioned war movie, so you know it’s only a matter of time before she winds up in some sort of contrived danger, and in need of rescue.
Far more intriguing, and believable, is the relationship between Ferris and Hoffman. It’s a joy to watch DiCaprio and Crowe verbally sparring, even though they infrequently share the same space: Most of their characters’ communication takes place over the phone.
DiCaprio is high-strung and arrogant; Crowe is low-key and arrogant and, in typically Method fashion, he put on 50 pounds for the part, and added a Southern drawl. This is his fourth film with Scott, following “Gladiator,” “A Good Year” and “American Gangster.”
Each character thinks that what he’s doing is the right course for the greater good. But when you break down “Body of Lies” to its most fundamental elements, it’s really about disagreeing with your boss. Hoffman gives Ferris an assignment, Ferris carries it out how he sees fit, they clash, then they start all over again.
It’s “Office Space” with more carnage, “9 to 5” where peril is present 24/7. Maybe this topic is relatable after all.
Next Article in Entertainment-Home
-
Role of His Life
When Hal Holbrook first donned heavy makeup to play an aged Mark Twain in a college campus performance in 1954, the actor was 29.
Now, after more than half a century of performing his one-man show, “Mark Twain Tonight,” Holbrook has to play a...
Events Calendar More Events Submit Event
- Police search for wanted Santa Rosa man
- Warriors' Morrow emerges with two impressive games
- Officer says woman tried to run him down in pickup
- Former fun center employee arrested on molest charges
- Singletary, Hill hoping to lose "interim" tags
- Kitchen fire causes $30,000 in damage
- Healdsburg police investigate possible sex attacks
- Santa Rosa Marine dies in drowning accident
- Hectic holiday travel ahead
- 101 tied up after truck tips
- ACLU seeks release of American 7 min ago
- Experts: State prisons too crowded 7 min ago
- Parents master educational maze 8 min ago
- LOS ANGELES $2.25 million settles harassment suit 8 min ago
- STOCKTON Defrocked priest sued in abuse case 8 min ago
- SAN DIEGO Medal of Honor appeal denied 8 min ago
- RIO VISTA Bankruptcy among options for town 8 min ago
- SACRAMENTO Pot plant seizures top 5 million 8 min ago
- Global warming gospel to spread around the world 8 min ago
- Report outlines grim outlook for salmon 8 min ago

Add a Comment
Only moderator-approved comments are shown on this page. To see all comments, please visit the forum.Post a comment | View all comments on this topic.